Google Removed Sidebar Ads – What Happened to Advertisers? Part Two

Nancy McCord
Nancy McCord – Point of View for Today.

Continued from Monday.

The full impact of what happens to AdWords advertisers is not known yet, but the data is flowing.

For now it appears that for advertisers not limited by budget:

  1. Clicks have dropped
  2. Impressions have dropped
  3. CTR has improved
  4. Average cost per click has increased about 5%
  5. Cost has dropped by about 1%
  6. Average position has increased by marginally
  7. Conversions have increased
  8. Cost per conversion has gone down
  9. Conversion rate has gone up

For advertisers with small ad spends and budget limited:

  1. Clicks have gone up
  2. Impressions have gone up
  3. CTR has declined
  4. Average cost per click has gone down about 3%
  5. Costs have gone up
  6. Average position has decreased significantly
  7. Conversions have dropped
  8. Cost per conversion has gone way up
  9. Conversion rate has gone down

Clearly for those with a limited budget the landscape of AdWords has changed and there is increased pressure from large advertisers wanting to fill the top spots. It may be that the drop in conversions is due to the fact that small budget programs now are showing in the off hours versus in prime time impacting click through rates and conversions.

I’ll know more as we get more statistical data, but for now, large advertisers won’t notice much of a change, but smaller advertisers with limited budgets will have to increase the cost per click to be more competitive now that ads only appear at the top and the bottom of the page at Google.com.

 

Google Removed Sidebar Ads – What Happened to Advertisers? Part One

Google Partner Badge
McCord Web Services is a Google Partner.

It may still be too soon to know what impact the removal of the sidebar ads from Google will have for AdWords advertisers, but here’s some of the data from the number of clients that we manage for the last month.

Client Results Not Limited by Budget – Large Ad Spends
Average clicks dropped 1.2% – some as much as 10%
Average impressions dropped 3.2% – some as much as 8.39% drop
Average cost per click increased 3.5% – some as much as 6.37%
Conversion rate increased by 14.1% – some as much as 44.95%
Average position dropped by 2.49% – some saw a 8.9% drop

Client Results Limited by Budget – Small Ad Spends
Average clicks increased by 18.8% – some by 59.8%
Average impressions increased by 23.7% – some by 42%
Average cost per click decreased by 7.5% some by 20.2%
Conversion rate decreased by 30.3% – some by 73%
Average position dropped by 16.2% – some by 27.6%

I expected to see a stronger increase in the cost per click and not a decrease. For lower spend accounts the big change was drop in ad position which caused a drop in conversion rate.

Come back on Wednesday for more details on the impact of Google’s removal of the right sidebar ads and what it means for you the AdWords advertiser.

 

 

AdWords Standard Beats AdWords Express

I had a client who wanted to promote a new service in Manhattan, New York but wanted to spend $200 to $300 for clicks for a 30 day period. The price of her service is about $900 a pop. She wanted to move back into an old AdWords Express program to try to generate some buzz.

Sounds like you should be able to quickly and efficiently do this right? But what kind of quality of clicks would you get with AdWords Express.

Here’s a concrete example.

Google Partner Badge
McCord Web Services is a Google Partner.

In AdWords Express we would enter one version of ad text and about 10 or so keywords we want to have the activity focus on.  Let’s say the service was permanent eyebrow tattoos. Once we entered in our keyword set, Google would use broad match variations, synonyms, plurals, similar words and even parts of our keyword we wanted ads to show on.

So, even if we really only wanted to show ads on permanent eyebrows, or permanent eyebrow tattoos, Google would show ads on eyebrows, eyebrow makeup, eyebrow powder, eyebrow tweasers. As an AdWord Standard Expert User, I consider this type of non-targeted advertising not worth the clicks that this type of program may generate. But, to get general makeup interested consumer traffic AdWords Express might be okay.

However, when you combine all this with the fact you may have to pay $1.25 to $3.75 a click, you will want to be pickier about who may see your ads so as to not blow through your AdWords budget and not end up with any real prospects.

From my viewpoint, there is simply no replacement for using the Standard AdWords program. Set up and management costs may be higher, but the results are “golden” in comparison.

Google Gets Serious About Mobile in New Announcement

Smartphones are here to stay make sure your website is mobile friendly.
Smartphones are here to stay make sure your website is mobile-friendly.

Just this past week Google announced that it was ramping up its organic sorting algorithm to enhance placement for mobile-friendly websites. The flip side of that is that sites that are not mobile-friendly will be getting pushed down in the listings.

Google did not a big caveat… If the site that is not mobile-friendly is the most relevant to the search query , it, the not mobile-friendly site may still be preferentially shown.

In lay terms, this announcement means that Google is totally jacked up on mobile and it is big business for them based on search trends and user demographics. Google has simply stated that having a mobile-friendly website is now no longer an after thought, but the new way to do business on the web.

What I know is that when Google says something, you’ve just got to listen. With many of our clients having over 50% of their website traffic from smartphones and more than 50% of AdWords clicks coming in from mobile devices, you’ve got to embrace the mobile experience. It is here to stay.