Google Ads Shows Year Over Year Click Cost Increases

Google Ads Icon

Search Engine Land, one of the pay per click industry’s top online magazines, has just published its statistical data analysis for Google Ads performance. Read the full article online. 

They identified the following information for 2023 vs. 2024. 

Search campaigns:
ROAS up 2% YoY
CPA down 3% YoY
CPC up 22% YoY
Conversion rate up 21% YoY

Performance Max campaigns:
ROAS: Up 1% YoY, from 609.77% in Q3 2023 to 616.36% in Q3 2024
CPA: Up 8% YoY, from $13.92 in Q3 2023 to $15.15 in Q3 2024
CPC: Up 6% YoY, from $0.50 in Q3 2023 to $0.53 in Q3 2024
Conversion Rate: Down 3% YoY, from 3.56% in Q3 2023 to 3.47% in Q3 2024

Shopping campaigns with PMax: 
ROAS up 4% YoY 
CPA down 15% YoY 
CPC down 10% YoY 
Conversion rate up 5% YoY 

What we find is that while most of our advertisers saw modest year-over-year gains in return on ad spend (ROAS) and conversion rates, the rising cost per click cost cut into those improvements. 

For some clients knowing that the cost per click has increased 22% from 2023 to 2024 is not news to them, but to others, seeing the actual data broken down my campaign type may be illuminating.

Although no one likes to have to increase their Google Ads spend budget just to stay competitive, the data points out that ad spend budgets should be reviewed regularly to keep your business competitive in the Google Ads auction. 

For existing clients, we are offering a free analysis in December to plan a 2025 Google Ads spend budget by month; allowing you to compete effectively in this changing landscape. Please let us know to add you to our 2025 budget planning session by December 10th  and receive a free Google Ads budget plan by month.  

If you are not a client yet, you can get a two year analysis and a 2025 Google Ads spend budget by month for $250. Please contact us by December 15th with payment.

AI and PPC: The Evolution of Advertising Strategies

AI's Impact on PPC Marketing Strategies and Google Ads

Pay-per-click (PPC) advertising has always been a dynamic field, constantly evolving with the introduction of new technologies and strategies. One of the most transformative forces in this space is artificial intelligence (AI). From keyword targeting to ad copy generation, AI is set to revolutionize how we approach PPC campaigns. In this blog post, we’ll explore the key ways in which AI will reshape PPC advertising, making it more effective and accessible for digital marketers, PPC specialists, and small business owners alike.

Refining Keyword Targeting

One of the most significant impacts AI will have on PPC is in the realm of keyword targeting. Traditionally, advertisers have relied on precise match keywords to ensure their ads reach the right audience. However, this approach often limits reach and can be costly. As AI technology becomes more advanced, it’s capable of refining broad match keyword targeting, making it more relevant and reducing the cost per click (CPC) for advertisers.

Moving to Broad Match Keywords

AI algorithms can analyze vast amounts of data to understand user intent better, allowing for more accurate broad match keyword targeting. This means that ads are more likely to be shown to users who are genuinely interested in the product or service being advertised, even if their search query doesn’t exactly match the keywords. Over time, this could lead to lower CPC and higher return on investment (ROI) for advertisers.

AI-Controlled Auction Time Bidding

While AI-controlled auction time bidding can optimize ad placements and improve budget efficiency, it also comes with potential pitfalls. Without proper oversight, it can artificially inflate the cost per acquisition (CPA), leading to skyrocketing expenses without a corresponding increase in conversions.

The Importance of Oversight

AI algorithms are designed to learn and adapt over time, but they still require human oversight to ensure they are making decisions that align with business goals. PPC specialists will play a crucial role in guiding AI decision-making to prevent inflated CPAs and maintain a balanced budget.

AI-Generated Content and Shopper Decision-Making

AI-generated content is another area where AI will have a profound impact on PPC advertising. As technology advances, AI can create more sophisticated, personalized ad copy that resonates with the target audience, thereby influencing shopper decision-making in a positive way.

Personalized Ad Copy

AI can analyze user data to generate customized ad copy that speaks directly to the needs and preferences of individual users. This level of personalization can lead to higher engagement rates and improved conversion rates, making PPC campaigns more effective. We believe AI-generated content will become increasingly sophisticated, allowing for highly personalized ad copy that will significantly impact shopper decision-making.

Smart Automation Tools

Smart automation tools powered by AI will continue to evolve, reducing the manual effort required in managing PPC campaigns. This will make PPC advertising more accessible for small business owners who may not have the resources to hire dedicated PPC specialists.

Accessible PPC for Small Businesses

AI-powered automation tools can handle tasks such as keyword research, bid management, and performance analysis, freeing up time for small business owners to focus on other aspects of their business. This democratization of PPC advertising will enable more small businesses to compete in the digital marketplace.

Preventing Click Fraud

Click fraud is a significant concern in PPC advertising, as it can drain budgets and reduce ROI. AI will play a crucial role in preventing click fraud by analyzing patterns and identifying fraudulent activity in real-time.

Ensuring Genuine Engagement

AI algorithms can detect and filter out suspicious clicks, ensuring that ad spend is directed towards genuine potential customers. This will help maintain the integrity of PPC campaigns and improve overall effectiveness.

The Evolving Role of PPC Specialists

As AI continues to advance, the role of PPC specialists will also evolve. While AI can handle many aspects of PPC management, human expertise will still be essential for strategic decision-making and oversight.

Guiding AI Decision-Making

PPC specialists will need to stay updated on the latest AI technologies and best practices to effectively guide AI decision-making. By combining AI capabilities with human expertise, PPC specialists can create highly effective and efficient campaigns.

Summing Up AI’s Impact on PPC Marketing Strategy

The future of PPC advertising is undoubtedly intertwined with the advancements in AI technology. From refining keyword targeting to generating personalized ad copy, AI is set to revolutionize how we approach PPC campaigns. As AI continues to evolve, digital marketers, PPC specialists, and small business owners must stay informed and adapt to leverage these advancements effectively.

By embracing AI and integrating it into their PPC strategies, businesses can achieve greater efficiency, improved ROI, and a competitive edge in the digital marketplace. The key will be to balance AI’s capabilities with human oversight and expertise, ensuring that AI-driven decisions align with overall business goals.

Ready to explore the future of PPC advertising with AI? Contact us your small business advertising specialists and improve your advertising strategy today.

Privacy First Marketing: The Future for Small Businesses

Lightbulb In Front of a First Party Advertising Team

In today’s online landscape, data privacy is no longer a fleeting concern but a pivotal aspect of digital marketing. With the rise of regulations like GDPR and more recently, the enforcement of iOS 14’s App Tracking Transparency framework, the concept of first-party data is quickly becoming the lodestar for businesses navigating the treacherous waters of digital advertising. For small business owners, this evolution represents both a challenge and an opportunity. Some may see it as a barrier to growth, while others harness the change to build a more solid relationship with their customers. Enter the concept of a privacy-first advertising agency.

What is a Privacy-First Advertising Agency?

At its core, a privacy-first advertising agency is one that pioneers in respecting user privacy by centering its digital marketing strategies around the use of first-party data. This approach not only guarantees adherence to privacy regulations but also fosters a climate of trust between brands and consumers. For small businesses, working with such an agency can mean a strategic revolution in their digital marketing tactics, resulting in enhanced customer loyalty and tangible business growth.

The Privacy Conundrum for Digital Marketers

The implications of user privacy on digital marketing are enormous. Traditional advertising strategies heavily rely on third-party cookies and shared user data to target consumers. However, growing privacy concerns, regulatory shifts, and the rise of privacy-focused technologies are reshaping the digital marketing landscape. This presents two fundamental challenges for businesses – how to stay compliant and how to maintain the effectiveness of their advertising efforts.

Leveraging First-Party Data

First-party data, comprising information collected directly from website visitors and customers, has become a goldmine for marketers. Unlike third-party data, first-party data is willingly shared by users, making it both privacy-safe and highly reliable. By harnessing their own customer insights, businesses can craft personalized marketing experiences that resonate with their audience on a deeper level, without infringing on their privacy.

Why First Party Data is the Holy Grail for Small Business Owners

For small business owners, the transition to first-party data can be daunting. Traditionally, they may not have had the resources or infrastructure to collect and analyze data in-house. However, with the emergence of user-friendly analytics tools and the optimization of customer data platforms, the acquisition and utilization of first-party data are now within reach.

Three Pillars of Utilizing First-Party Data

The strategic use of first-party data relies on three fundamental pillars:

  • Data Collection and Enrichment: Small businesses can collect user data at various touchpoints and enrich this information with contextual, behavioral, and transactional data to create robust customer profiles.
  • Targeting and Segmentation: By employing sophisticated targeting and segmentation techniques, small businesses can reach out to their audience with tailored messaging that aligns with their interests and purchase intent.
  • Measurement and Optimization: Implementing mechanisms to measure the performance of marketing campaigns helps in understanding user behavior, refining strategies, and driving better results.

Real-World Success Stories

Small businesses that have embraced a first-party data-driven strategy have witnessed remarkable transformations in their marketing efforts. For instance, local e-commerce boutiques have seen a significant uptick in conversion rates by offering personalized ad experiences based on first-party insights. Tech startups have achieved cost savings and improved ROI on their advertising expenditure through accurate audience targeting. Likewise, service-oriented businesses have fostered loyalty by prioritizing user consent and transparency in their marketing communications.

Finding the Right Privacy First Advertising Agency

Selecting the right privacy-forward partner for your digital marketing is crucial. It requires due diligence and a compatibility check to ensure that the agency’s ethos aligns with your business objectives.

Key Considerations When Choosing an Agency

  • Proven Experience: Look for agencies that have a track record of successfully transitioning clients to first-party data strategies.
  • Compliance Expertise: Consider agencies that have a strong understanding of privacy regulations and can help you stay compliant.
  • Innovative Solutions: Partner with agencies that offer innovative approaches, such as context-based advertising, that do not rely on third-party data.
  • Transparent Practices: Agencies that prioritize transparency in their data handling processes and offer clear insights into their methodologies are preferable.

Case Studies Highlighting the Success of First-Party Data

The success of businesses employing first-party data strategies is not just anecdotal; it’s backed by tangible results. When the alignment between agency and business goals is perfect, the potential for growth is enormous. Case studies showcase the power of first-party data in delivering improved ROI, enhanced user engagement, and sustainable brand-consumer relationships.

The Road Ahead: Tips for Small Business Owners

Adapting to the privacy-first paradigm necessitates a shift in mindset and operations.

Practical Steps to Prepare for the Transition

  • Educate your Team: Creating awareness among your staff about the importance of user privacy and the role of first-party data is critical.
  • Optimize Data Collection: Refine your data collection methods to ensure they comply with privacy regulations and focus on quality and relevance.
  • Invest in Relationships: Dedicate resources to building direct, one-to-one relationships with your customers to better understand and serve them.
  • Stay Informed: The digital marketing landscape is continually evolving. Stay up to date with the latest trends and best practices related to privacy-first advertising.

The Long-Term Benefits of a Privacy-First Approach

A long-term commitment to privacy-first marketing is an investment in your business’s sustainability. It not only future-proofs your digital marketing efforts against the shifting legislative sands but also builds a solid foundation of trust with your customers.

Wrapping Up First-Party Advertising

The shift towards privacy-first advertising is more than a trend; it’s a fundamental reevaluation of the digital marketing ecosystem. Small business owners that recognize the value of this approach and proactively engage with privacy-first agencies stand to reap substantial benefits. Privacy-first marketing is not a challenge to be overcome but an opportunity to be seized. In the evolving digital marketplace, small business success may well hinge on your ability to adapt and thrive within the privacy-first framework. Contact us your privacy first advertising agency to get your business in front of the right customers.

How to Win the Holiday Ecommerce Season in 2023

Holiday Search Trends and Google Ads Strategies
Holiday Search Trends and Google Ads Strategies
Holiday Google Shopping Trends

The holiday ecommerce season is off to a slow start, with Q4 sales growing just +1.4% YoY as of Nov 4, according to Mastercard. However, the holiday season is far from over with only 33% of holiday shopping complete so far. But that doesn’t mean that shoppers aren’t active. It is reported that 79% of shoppers say they’ll be researching their purchases before buying them.

Google Search Trends & Market Reports

So, what will the rest of Q4 look like? Well, it depends on who you ask. Forecasts in the CA market range from -11% according to Deloitte, all the way to +15% according to RCC/Leger.

This is a season of extremes: We see this in our own data, and Google reports searches for “food banks” surging by 52% YoY while at the same time luxury retail searches increase by +12% YoY.

Consumer intent is up: Google report an undeniable surge in real-time shopping intent – so far this Q4. Searches across all retail categories have increased YoY +14%, a signal that stronger pent-up sales may actually be around the corner.

Holiday Season Digital Marketing Strategies

Rather than C5 (Cyber 5 day shopping), consider the Cyber fortnight, as the intense buying period lasts 12 days now, not 5. In analyzing Mastercard spending behavior within key gifting categories over the last few years, it was uncovered that the average spend/day on the “shoulder days” – the ramp in and out of Cyber – are almost as high as the average during C5 itself.

Implications/Actions: Even in a world of decreased spend, there are more opportunities than ever to reach shoppers if you are showing up in the right places.

Deal days have never been more important. Early deal seekers are already on the hunt for bargains, and you don’t want to miss out on this lucrative segment. Here are some tips to make the most of your deal days strategy:

– Start early and end late: Extend your promotions beyond the traditional Black Friday and Cyber Monday dates. Shoppers are looking for deals throughout November and December, so don’t limit yourself to a few days.

– Be clear and consistent: Make sure your deals are easy to find and understand on your website, social media, email, and ads. Use clear and consistent messaging across all channels to avoid confusion and frustration.

– Optimize for mobile: More than half of online shoppers will use their smartphones to research and buy products this holiday season. Make sure your website is mobile-friendly, fast, and secure. Use mobile-specific features like click-to-call, location extensions, and app downloads to drive conversions.

– Track and measure: Use analytics tools like Google Analytics and Google Ads to track your performance and measure your return on investment. Identify what does and doesn’t work and adjust your strategy accordingly.

Finish Out The Holiday eCommerce Season with a Strong Marketing Strategy

The holiday ecommerce season is not over yet. There is still time for online retailers to turn things around and end the year on a high note. By adapting to the changing market conditions and customer needs, you can create a memorable and satisfying shopping experience for your customers and increase your sales and profits.